Top 5 Woods for Hardwood Floors: Expert Review

Imagine stepping onto a floor that feels warm underfoot, boasts a rich color, and tells a story with every grain. Hardwood floors bring natural beauty right into your home. But when it comes to choosing the perfect wood, the options can feel overwhelming. Should you pick Oak for its strength, Maple for its light look, or maybe something exotic? Many homeowners feel stuck, worrying about durability, cost, and how the wood will look years down the road.

Selecting the wrong wood can lead to scratches, dents, or a look that fades quickly. You want a floor that lasts and matches your home’s style perfectly. This guide cuts through the confusion. We break down the most popular hardwood choices, explaining what makes each one unique.

By the end of this post, you will know exactly which wood species best fits your lifestyle and budget. Ready to transform your space with flooring you will love for decades? Let’s dive into the wonderful world of hardwood options and find your perfect match.

Top Wood For Hardwood Floors Recommendations

No. 1
Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner Spray - 32 fl oz - Residue-Free Floor Cleaning Solution for Wood Floors
  • Residue-free, fast drying solution that removes dust, dirt and grime to reveal the floor's natural shine
  • Quick and easy to use. Just spray, mop, and refill
  • Refill with any economy-size Bona floor cleaner refill or Bona concentrate packet
  • Protect your floor from discoloration and harm with our pH-neutral formulation. Safe for all unwaxed, unoiled, polyurethane finished wood floors
  • Formulation contains 95% USDA certified biobased content. Meets the U.S. EPA product standards and is Safer Choice Certified
No. 2
Bona Hardwood Floor Polish - 32 fl oz - High Gloss Shine - Polish for Wood Floors - Protects and Renews Dull Flooring - Covers 500 sq ft
  • This product is not a floor cleaner
  • Designed to be safe for all unwaxed, unoiled, polyurethane finished wood floors
  • Bring dull wood floors back to life with a high gloss shine
  • Adds a protective layer & fills in micro-scratches while evening out the appearance of the floor
  • Coverage rate by square footage: One 24oz. bottle covers 350 square feet of flooring; One 32oz. bottle covers 500 square feet of flooring; One 36oz. bottle covers 550 square feet of flooring
No. 3
Rejuvenate Professional Wood Floor Restorer Fills Scratches, Shines And Protects Wood Flooring For A High Gloss Shine, 32 Ounces
  • PROFESSIONAL WOOD FLOOR RESTORER: Restores wood floors, leaving them with a beautiful glossy finish
  • 1-COAT APPLICATION: A single, easy-to-apply coat fills in scratches, shines & protects
  • REVITALIZING FORMULA: Revitalizes wood floors throughout the home for long-lasting protection
  • FOR BEST RESULTS: Use with Rejuvenate Wood Floor Cleaner to gently clean & enhance your floor’s natural hardwood beauty
  • SAFE FOR PETS & KIDS: When used per directions on product label. For additional details, visit rejuvenateproducts.com/safe.
No. 4
Bona Hardwood Floor Cleaner Refill - 128 fl oz - Unscented - Refill for Bona Spray Mops and Spray Bottles - Residue-Free Floor Cleaning Solution for Wood Floors
  • Easily refill any Bona floor cleaner spray bottle or mop cartridge
  • Residue-free, fast drying solution that removes dust, dirt and grime to reveal the floor's natural shine
  • Splashless technology and a wide handle provide extra control for a smooth pour
  • Protect your floor from discoloration and harm with our pH-neutral formulation; Safe for all unwaxed, unoiled, polyurethane finished wood floors
  • Formulation contains 95% USDA certified biobased content; Meets the U.S. EPA product standards and is Safer Choice Certified
No. 5
Weiman Hardwood Floor Cleaner and Polish Restorer Combo - 2 Pack - High-Traffic Hardwood Floor, Natural Shine, Removes Scratches, Leaves Protective Layer
  • Restore - Micro-filling technology removes scratches while forming a protective scratch resistant layer
  • Versatile - Can be used on any finished hardwood surface, rejuvenating a shine with no sticky residue
  • Safer - This "ready to use" formula can be used around kids and pets without causing harm
  • Simple - Clean surface while also extending the life of your wood floors in just one easy step
  • Use On - Only FINISHED hardwood, engineered hardwood, vinyl, and laminate floors, may be used with refillable squirt mops
No. 6
Weiman Hardwood Cleaner for Finished Hardwood Floors, Engineered Floors, Laminate - Streak-Free Results, EPA Safer Choice Certified, 32 oz
  • Streak-Free - Specifically formulated to clean finished hardwood floors without streaking or dulling
  • Versatile - Can be used on any finished hardwood surface, rejuvenating a shine with no sticky residue
  • Safe - Plant based ingredients that's safe for kids and pets to walk on after the solution has dried
  • Recommended - Use with Weiman High Traffic Hardwood Floor Polish to experience long lasting results and a beautiful shine
  • Use On - Only FINISHED hardwood, engineered hardwood, vinyl, and laminate floors, may be used with refillable squirt mops
No. 7
Weiman Wood Floor Polish and Restorer 32 Oz 3PC Bundle - High-Traffic Hardwood Floor, Natural Shine, Removes Scratches, Leaves Protective Layer
  • MICRO-FILLING TECHNOLOGY FOR SCRATCHES: Our Micro-filling technology removes scratches on high traffic hardwood floors while forming a protective scratch resistant layer. It doesn’t just fade existing scratches; it contains a micro-filling technology that prevents new ones from forming!
  • RESTORES AND SHINES HARDWOOD: Instantly rejuvenates finished hardwood floors with a brilliant, natural suppleness & sheen that extends the life of wood floors and leaves them looking like new again!
  • SAFE AROUND CHILDREN AND PETS: This "ready to use" formula can be used around kids and pets without causing harm
  • MULITPLE USES: Can be used on any finished hardwood surface, rejuvenating a shine that leaves no sticky residue
  • FOR BEST RESULTS: Use with Weiman Hardwood Floor Cleaner to experience long lasting results.
No. 8
Weiman Wood Floor Polish and Restorer 32 Oz Bundle - High-Traffic Hardwood Floor, Natural Shine, Removes Scratches, Leaves Protective Layer
  • RESTORES AND SHINES HARDWOOD: Instantly rejuvenates finished hardwood floors with a brilliant, natural suppleness & sheen that extends the life of wood floors and leaves them looking like new!
  • MULITPLE USES: Can be used on any finished hardwood surface, rejuvenating a shine that leaves no sticky residue
  • MICRO-FILLING TECHNOLOGY FOR SCRATCHES: Our Micro-filling technology removes scratches on high traffic hardwood floors while forming a protective scratch resistant layer. It doesn’t just fade existing scratches; it contains a micro-filling technology that prevents new ones from forming!
  • FOR BEST RESULTS: Use with Weiman Hardwood Floor Cleaner to experience long lasting results. All Weiman products are proudly manufactured in the USA using US and imported parts.
  • SAFE AROUND CHILDREN AND PETS: This "ready to use" formula can be used around kids and pets without causing harm

Choosing the Best Wood for Your Hardwood Floors: A Buyer’s Guide

Selecting the right wood for your new hardwood floors is a big decision. The wood you choose affects how your floor looks, how long it lasts, and how much it costs. This guide helps you understand what to look for so you can pick the perfect wood for your home.

Key Features to Look For

When shopping for hardwood, several features really matter. Pay close attention to these points:

Durability and Hardness (Janka Rating)

  • Janka Hardness Scale: This scale measures how easily wood dents. Higher numbers mean harder wood. Harder woods resist scratches and dents better.
  • Use Case Match: If you have pets or a busy family, choose a high Janka rating (like Hickory or Brazilian Cherry). For a quiet, low-traffic room, a medium rating might work.

Grain Pattern and Appearance

  • Grain: This is the look of the wood lines. Some woods, like Oak, have very visible, strong grain patterns. Others, like Maple, have a smoother, quieter look.
  • Color: Wood colors range from light (like Ash) to dark (like Walnut). Consider how the color matches your walls and furniture.

Stability

Wood naturally expands and contracts with changes in temperature and humidity. Look for woods known for good stability, especially if you live in an area with big seasonal weather swings.

Important Wood Materials

Not all hardwoods are created equal. Here are some common and popular choices:

Domestic Hardwoods

  • Red Oak: This is the most popular choice. It is strong, takes stains well, and is widely available.
  • Maple: It is very hard and has a light, uniform appearance. It resists dents well.
  • Hickory: This wood has the highest Janka rating among common domestic options. It shows off a lot of color variation.

Exotic Hardwoods

  • Brazilian Cherry (Jatoba): These woods are often much harder than Oak. They have rich, deep red and brown colors that darken over time.
  • Teak: Known for its natural oils, Teak resists moisture very well, making it good for certain areas.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

The quality of your final floor depends on more than just the species of wood.

Factors That Improve Quality

  • Kiln Drying: Wood that is properly kiln-dried (dried in a special oven) has less moisture inside. This makes the wood much more stable after installation.
  • Clear Grade Lumber: Higher quality boards have fewer knots or natural defects. This gives you a more consistent and premium look.
  • Engineered vs. Solid: Engineered wood (layers glued together with a real wood veneer on top) often handles moisture changes better than solid wood.

Factors That Reduce Quality

  • Poor Milling: If the edges or thickness of the boards are not perfectly uniform, the floor will look uneven when installed.
  • Air-Dried Wood: Wood dried only by air can hold too much moisture, leading to gaps or warping later.

User Experience and Use Cases

Think about where the floor will go and who will use it. This helps you decide on the right wood.

High-Traffic Areas (Kitchens, Hallways)

You need maximum durability here. Select very hard woods like Hickory or Brazilian Cherry. A floor with a lot of natural grain variation (like Oak) hides scratches better than a very uniform floor.

Bedrooms and Living Rooms

Comfort and look are key here. You can use slightly softer woods like Walnut or Maple. Focus more on the color and grain that fits your decorating style.

Moisture Concerns (Basements)

Solid wood is usually a poor choice for basements due to high moisture. Engineered hardwood is a much better option because its layered construction resists moisture better. Some woods, like Teak, offer natural moisture resistance.


10 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) About Hardwood Flooring

Q: What is the Janka rating, and why does it matter?

A: The Janka rating tells you how hard the wood is. A higher number means the wood resists dents and scratches better. It is very important for busy homes.

Q: Is solid wood or engineered wood better?

A: Solid wood is one thick piece. Engineered wood has layers glued together with a top layer of real wood. Engineered wood handles moisture changes better, making it good for areas below ground level.

Q: Which wood is the most scratch-resistant?

A: Generally, woods with the highest Janka ratings are the most scratch-resistant. Hickory and some exotic woods usually win this category.

Q: Can I stain any type of wood?

A: Most woods take stain well, but Oak is the easiest to stain evenly. Very dense exotic woods sometimes resist stain or require special prep work.

Q: How do I know if the wood is dried correctly?

A: Good suppliers use kiln drying, which removes most of the moisture. Ask the seller what moisture content their wood has. It should be around 6% to 9%.

Q: What is the difference between grain and color?

A: Grain is the pattern of lines in the wood, like stripes or swirls. Color is the actual shade, from light tan to dark brown.

Q: Will my hardwood floor change color over time?

A: Yes. Most wood darkens or changes tone when exposed to sunlight. For example, Brazilian Cherry starts reddish and turns a deeper brown.

Q: Is Oak a good choice for a first-time buyer?

A: Yes, Oak is often recommended. It is durable, widely available, accepts stain colors easily, and is a good middle-ground price.

Q: What wood should I avoid if I have pets?

A: Avoid very soft woods like Pine or softer grades of Maple. These woods will show dents and scratches very easily from pet claws.

Q: Does the width of the plank affect quality?

A: Plank width does not directly affect wood quality, but wider planks can sometimes show the natural movement (expansion/contraction) of the wood more than narrow planks.

Leave a Comment