How Can I Kill Wild Onions In My Yard Permanently?

Getting rid of wild onions in your yard for good is a common problem for many homeowners, and while it’s hard, it is possible with the right plan and patience. You can kill wild onions permanently by using a mix of methods: correctly telling them apart from grass, picking the best time to treat them, using different ways like carefully digging them up, applying the right plant killers (herbicides) that won’t hurt your grass, trying natural methods, and stopping new ones from growing. It takes time and repeated effort because of how they grow from small bulbs underground.

Image Source: www.solutionsstores.com

Grasping the Challenge of Wild Onions

Wild onions and their close cousin, wild garlic, are stubborn weeds. They pop up in lawns, gardens, and flower beds. They look like grass but smell like onion or garlic when you cut or crush them. Getting rid of them is tricky because they grow from small bulbs deep in the soil. These bulbs can break off easily, leaving pieces behind to grow new plants. Also, they make lots of tiny bulbs called bulblets, and some even make seeds. This means you need a plan that attacks the plant above ground and the bulbs below.

Identifying Wild Onion and Wild Garlic

Knowing if you have wild onion or wild garlic is the first step. People often call them by the same name because they are very similar and you control them in much the same way.

Wild Onion Identification

Wild onion (Allium canadense) has flat leaves. The leaves start from the base of the plant and look a lot like grass blades, but they are flat and solid. The flower head often has small bulbs mixed in with the flowers.

Wild Garlic Control

Wild garlic (Allium vineale) has round, hollow leaves. These leaves are like thin tubes. They grow from the base and along the lower part of the stem. The flower head mostly has small bulbs (called bulbils) instead of true flowers.

Both plants spread mainly by the bulbs and bulblets in the ground. Wild garlic is often seen as more aggressive in lawns because it makes more underground bulblets.

Look for these signs:

Smell: Crush a leaf. If it smells like onion or garlic, it’s one of them.
Leaves: Are they flat (wild onion) or round and hollow (wild garlic)?
Growth: They usually pop up in late fall or early spring. They grow through the winter and die back in summer heat.

Why These Weeds Are So Tough

Wild onions and wild garlic are hard to kill permanently because of their life cycle.

Bulbs: The main plant grows from a bulb underground. This bulb stores food.
Bulblets: The main bulb makes new small bulbs (bulblets) around it. These bulblets are like tiny copies ready to grow. Wild garlic is famous for making many bulblets.
Aerial Bulbils: The plant makes small bulbs at the top of the stalk where flowers would be. These can fall off and start new plants.
Seeds: Some plants also make true seeds, adding another way they spread.

If you just cut the tops off, the bulbs underground are usually fine and will just send up new leaves. If you try to dig them, small bulblets can break off and stay in the soil, leading to new growth. The waxy surface of the leaves also makes it hard for liquid weed killers to stick and get inside the plant.

When to Treat Wild Onions for Best Results

Timing your attack is very important. Wild onions and garlic are cool-season plants. This means they grow actively when the weather is cool.

Best Time to Attack

The best times to treat wild onions are in the late fall and late winter or early spring.

Late Fall: The plants sprout in the fall. They are actively growing and storing energy in their bulbs for winter. Applying a weed killer at this time is effective because the plant pulls the chemical down into the bulbs. This is a key time for herbicide use.
Late Winter / Early Spring: Before the plants start to make their flower/seed stalks, they are again actively growing. This is another good window for treatment, especially with herbicides. Treating before they make new bulblets or seeds stops them from spreading further that year.

Treating in the summer is usually not as helpful. The plants are often dormant or dying back from the heat. Weed killers won’t work well because the plant isn’t actively taking things in.

Repeating treatment is key because not all bulbs may sprout at the same time, and you need to get new growth.

Methods for Getting Rid of Wild Onions

You have a few main ways to fight wild onions: pulling them by hand, using chemicals, or using natural methods. Often, the best approach uses more than one method.

Digging Up Wild Onions

This is a good method for small groups of plants or if you want to avoid chemicals (organic wild onion removal).

How to Dig Effectively

Moist Soil: Water the area or wait until after rain. Moist soil makes it easier to lift the bulbs without breaking them off.
Use the Right Tool: A small trowel or garden spade works well.
Dig Deep and Wide: Don’t just pull the leaves. Dig a few inches deep and wide around the plant.
Lift Carefully: Gently lift the soil and the plant. The goal is to get the main bulb and all the small bulblets around it.
Check the Soil: Look through the soil you removed to find any stray bulbs or bulblets.
Dispose Properly: Do not put the plants or bulbs in your compost pile unless you know your compost gets very hot. The bulbs can survive and spread from there. Bag them and throw them in the trash.
Fill the Hole: Fill the small hole with soil.

Pros and Cons of Digging

Pros: No chemicals needed (how to get rid of wild onions naturally). Can be very effective if you get all the bulbs. Good for small areas.
Cons: Very time-consuming for large areas. If you leave even one bulblet, it will grow back. Can disturb the soil and potentially bring up new weed seeds.

Using Herbicides to Kill Wild Onions

Chemical weed killers (herbicides) can be effective, especially for larger areas or when digging is not practical.

Best Herbicide Wild Onions

For killing wild onions and wild garlic in lawns, you need a selective herbicide.

Selective Herbicide Wild Onion

A selective herbicide means it kills certain types of plants but not others. For lawns, you want a herbicide that kills “broadleaf” weeds (like wild onions, dandelions, clover) but leaves the grass (a “grassy” plant) unharmed. This is how you achieve killing wild onions without killing grass.

Look for products that contain one or more of these active ingredients:

2,4-D
MCPP (Mecoprop)
Dicamba
Triclopyr

Many common “weed-and-feed” products or liquid lawn weed killers contain a mix of these.

How Herbicides Work on Wild Onions

These chemicals are “post-emergent” herbicides. This means they kill plants that have already sprouted. When you spray the leaves, the plant takes the chemical in and moves it down to the bulbs, killing the whole plant.

Applying Herbicides Safely and Effectively

Read the Label: Always read and follow the instructions on the herbicide product label. This tells you how much to use, how to mix it, when and where to apply it, and safety steps.
Timing: Apply in late fall or late winter/early spring when plants are actively growing. Avoid applying during hot summer months or when temperatures are below freezing.
Weather: Apply on a calm day with no wind to avoid drift onto desired plants. Rain after application can wash the chemical away; check the label for how long it needs to be dry. Usually, a few hours is enough.
Apply to Leaves: Spray the leaves of the wild onions directly. The plant absorbs the chemical through the leaves. A sprayer with a narrow stream can help target the weeds and avoid spraying too much grass.
Repeat Applications: You will almost certainly need to apply the herbicide more than once. The first application might kill the main plant, but new bulblets may sprout later. Wait the time recommended on the label (usually a few weeks) and spray any new growth you see. Several applications over two seasons might be needed for full control.
Dormant Grass: Some labels suggest applying when grass is dormant (not actively growing, often in winter). This can be safe for the grass while still hitting the actively growing wild onions. Check your specific grass type and the herbicide label.

Pros and Cons of Herbicides

Pros: Effective for large infestations. Kills the plant down to the bulb. Can be applied to lawns without killing the grass (killing wild onions without killing grass).
Cons: Chemicals are used (some people prefer not to). Requires careful application. May take multiple treatments. Can take a week or two to see results.

How to Get Rid of Wild Onions Naturally

If you prefer not to use chemical herbicides, there are natural and organic methods. These often require more effort and repetition than chemicals.

Organic Wild Onion Removal Methods

Careful Digging: As mentioned above, careful and thorough digging is the primary organic wild onion removal method. It’s best for small areas.
Boiling Water: Pouring boiling water directly onto the plants can kill them above ground and might damage the bulbs. This is only good for very small, isolated patches, like cracks in pavement, as it will kill everything it touches, including grass or desired plants.
Vinegar: A strong vinegar solution (like horticultural vinegar, which is stronger than kitchen vinegar) can burn the tops off wild onions. Mix a strong vinegar (20% acetic acid is much stronger than typical 5% kitchen vinegar) with a little dish soap (which helps it stick to the waxy leaves). Spray directly on the leaves.
- Pros: Natural. Kills above-ground growth.
- Cons: Usually does not kill the bulbs underground. The plant will likely grow back. Requires repeated application. Will kill grass and other plants it hits.
Smothering: For patches in garden beds (not lawns), you can cover the area with thick black plastic or cardboard and mulch for at least several months. This blocks light and can weaken or kill the plants and bulbs.
Corn Gluten Meal: This is often sold as a natural weed preventer. It works by stopping seeds from sprouting. It won’t kill existing wild onions or bulbs, but it might help prevent new seeds from growing if the plants have gone to seed. This is more about preventing wild onions than killing existing ones.

Combining Natural Methods

Often, the best natural approach is repeated digging as soon as you see new growth. This weakens the bulbs over time. Using boiling water or vinegar can knock back the tops, but you still need to deal with the bulbs.

Pros and Cons of Natural Methods

Pros: No harsh chemicals are used (how to get rid of wild onions naturally). Safe for pets and kids after application.
Cons: Often less effective at killing the underground bulbs compared to systemic herbicides. Requires more frequent and consistent effort. May take much longer to see significant results.

Putting It All Together: An Integrated Plan

To permanently get rid of wild onions, you need a long-term strategy that combines different methods.

Identify: Be sure it’s wild onion or garlic.
Assess: How big is the problem? A few plants or a whole lawn? This helps decide which methods are best.
Timing: Plan your attack for late fall and late winter/early spring.
Initial Attack:
- For small patches: Dig carefully, making sure to get all bulbs.
- For large areas in lawns: Apply a selective herbicide designed for broadleaf weeds in grass.
- For large areas in garden beds: Consider careful digging or smothering.
Repeat: This is the most crucial step. Check the area regularly. As soon as you see new growth (which will happen as new bulblets sprout), treat again.
- If digging: Dig them up again carefully.
- If using herbicide: Spray the new growth.
Keep Watching: Continue monitoring the area in the fall and spring for several years.

Stopping Them From Coming Back: Preventing Wild Onions

Killing the existing plants is only half the battle. You need to make your yard less welcoming to them. This is preventing wild onions.

Maintain a Healthy, Thick Lawn: Dense grass crowds out weeds. Water and fertilize your lawn properly. Mow at the right height (usually higher is better) to shade the soil and keep weeds from getting started.
Mulch Garden Beds: Use a thick layer (2-3 inches) of mulch in garden beds. This blocks sunlight and makes it hard for wild onions to sprout.
Address Thin Areas: If your lawn has bare or thin spots, wild onions can easily move in. Seed or sod these areas to create thick turf.
Check New Plants/Soil: Sometimes, bulbs can come into your yard mixed in with new plants you buy or soil you bring in. Check carefully before planting.
Edge Beds: Using edging around garden beds can help stop weeds from creeping in from the lawn or nearby areas.
Be Vigilant: Regularly walk your yard and remove any wild onions you see immediately before they have a chance to make more bulbs or seeds.

Dealing with Different Yard Areas

In the Lawn: Selective herbicides are often the most practical solution for large areas, combined with digging out smaller, stubborn patches. Maintaining a thick lawn is vital for prevention.
In Garden Beds: Digging is usually preferred to avoid killing desired plants. Mulching is an excellent preventative. Spot-treating with boiling water or horticultural vinegar is possible for small, isolated plants, but be very careful not to hit your flowers or shrubs. Smothering large, infested beds before planting can also work.

Comparing Methods

Here is a simple look at the different ways to fight wild onions:

Method	Best Use Case	Effectiveness (Killing Bulbs)	Effort Level	Time to Results	Impact on Grass/Other Plants	Organic/Natural?
Digging	Small patches, garden beds	High (if done perfectly)	High	Immediate (plant gone)	Low (if careful)	Yes
Selective Herbicide	Large lawn areas	High (needs repeat)	Medium	Weeks	Low (kills weeds, not grass)	No
Boiling Water	Very small cracks/isolated spots	Low (damages tops, maybe bulb)	Low (per plant)	Immediate (tops die)	High (kills everything)	Yes
Vinegar (Strong)	Small patches, garden beds	Low (damages tops)	Medium	Days (tops die)	High (kills everything)	Yes
Smothering	Large beds without plants	Medium-High	Low (after setup)	Months	High (kills everything)	Yes

Persistence Pays Off

Getting rid of wild onions permanently is not a quick fix. You will likely see new plants pop up for a year or two, even after treatment. This is normal and happens as dormant bulbs sprout. The key is to keep checking and treating the new growth as soon as you see it. Each time a plant is killed before it can make new bulbs, you reduce the total number of bulbs in the soil. Over time, with consistent effort, you can greatly reduce and possibly eliminate them from your yard. Think of it as a marathon, not a sprint.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I just mow wild onions?

Mowing wild onions just cuts the tops off. This weakens the plant a little but usually does not kill the underground bulbs. The bulbs will just send up new leaves. Mowing won’t get rid of them permanently, but it can help keep them from making seeds or aerial bulblets if done before they flower.

Will wild onions die in the summer heat?

Wild onions and wild garlic are cool-season plants. The tops will often die back or go dormant during the hot summer months. However, the bulbs remain alive underground, waiting for cooler weather in the fall to start growing again.

How long does it take to kill wild onions with herbicide?

After spraying a selective herbicide, you should start to see the wild onions wilting and turning yellow within a week to ten days. It might take two weeks or longer for the plant to fully die. Remember, repeat applications are needed because new plants will likely sprout from existing bulblets.

Do wild onions spread easily?

Yes, very easily. They spread mainly by underground bulbs and bulblets, which multiply each year. Wild garlic is especially good at making lots of tiny bulblets. They can also spread by small bulbs produced at the top of the plant or sometimes by seeds.

Is it safe to eat wild onions from my yard?

While the plants are technically edible, it’s generally not recommended to eat wild onions or garlic found in areas that might have been treated with pesticides or herbicides. It’s safer to stick to cultivated varieties. Also, be absolutely sure of your identification, as some poisonous plants can look similar to onions or garlic (though they won’t have the distinct onion/garlic smell).

Can I use salt to kill wild onions?

Salt can kill plants by drying them out and changing the soil chemistry. However, using salt in your yard is a bad idea. It will kill everything it touches, including your grass and any other plants, and it can make the soil unsuitable for growing anything for a long time. It’s not a good method for lawn or garden areas.

What time of year are wild onions most visible?

Wild onions and wild garlic are most visible and actively growing during the cooler months: late fall, winter, and early spring. They are often the first green things you see popping up in the lawn as the weather cools down, and they stand out against dormant grass.

Will a weed killer like Roundup kill wild onions?

Yes, non-selective weed killers like glyphosate (the main ingredient in Roundup) will kill wild onions. However, they will also kill any other plant they touch, including your grass. These are only suitable for areas where you want to kill everything, like cracks in pavement or areas you plan to replant entirely. They are not suitable for use in the middle of a lawn if you want to keep the grass. A selective herbicide is needed for killing wild onions without killing grass.

By being patient, using the right methods at the right time, and staying watchful, you can win the battle against wild onions and enjoy a yard free of these smelly weeds.