Can You Use Railroad Ties For Raised Garden Beds – Is It Safe?

Image Source: cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net

Can You Use Railroad Ties For Raised Garden Beds – Is It Safe?

You might ask, “Can you use railroad ties for raised garden beds?” The short answer is yes, you can physically build raised beds with railroad ties, but is it safe? For most home gardens, especially those where you plan to grow food, the answer is a strong no. Railroad ties are treated with chemicals that can be harmful and can leach into the soil, creating risks for your plants and your health. This article will tell you why many gardeners avoid them and what safer options you have.

Why People Consider Railroad Ties

Many people look at old railroad ties and see a simple way to build garden beds. They might seem like a good choice for a few reasons:

• They cost little or no money. Old ties are often free or very cheap to get. This makes them seem like a budget-friendly choice.
• They are big and strong. Railroad ties are heavy pieces of wood. They look like they can make a solid, lasting frame for a raised bed.
• They are easy to find. In some areas, old ties are easy to come by, especially near old train tracks or construction sites.
• They have a rustic look. Some people like the rugged look they give to a garden.

But these reasons don’t tell the whole story. The real issue is not how they look or feel, but what is in the wood.

The Main Worry: Creosote

Railroad ties are treated wood. They are treated with a substance called creosote. This is done to stop the wood from rotting. It helps the ties last a very long time, even when buried in the ground and exposed to weather.

Creosote is made by heating coal or wood at high heat. Coal-tar creosote is the most common type used for railroad ties. It’s a mix of many different chemicals. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) lists coal-tar creosote as a probable human carcinogen. This means it might cause cancer in people.

The process of treating the wood pushes the creosote deep into the fibers of the tie. It is not just on the surface.

Shedding Light On the Risks

Using railroad ties for garden beds brings several risks. These risks come from the chemicals inside the ties.

Toxic Chemicals in Garden Beds

Creosote is full of chemicals called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). There can be hundreds of different PAHs in creosote. Many of these chemicals are known to be harmful. Some are linked to cancer. Others can hurt your skin, eyes, or breathing.

When you put creosote railroad ties in your garden, you are putting these toxic chemicals in garden beds. They sit right there, next to the soil where you want to grow healthy plants.

Leaching From Railroad Ties Into Soil

This is a big problem. The chemicals in the ties do not just stay put. They can move out of the wood and into the surrounding soil. This process is called leaching from railroad ties into soil.

Several things make leaching happen:

• Water: Rain, watering your garden, and moisture in the soil can dissolve chemicals from the wood. This water then carries the chemicals into the dirt.
• Heat: Warm temperatures can make the chemicals more likely to move out of the wood. The sun heating the ties can increase leaching.
• Soil Type: The type of soil you have can affect how much and how fast chemicals move.
• Age of Ties: Some people think old ties are safe because they have been exposed for a long time. But studies show that even very old ties can still leach harmful amounts of creosote into the soil. The chemicals stick around for many years.

Once these chemicals are in the soil, they can spread. They can get into the roots of your plants.

Health Risks of Railroad Tie Gardens

The chemicals leaching from the ties can cause health risks of railroad tie gardens. These risks affect both people and possibly plants.

• Skin Contact: Touching the ties can cause skin irritation, burns, or rashes. The oils in creosote can be harsh. You should always wear gloves if you handle them.
• Breathing Issues: The ties can give off fumes, especially on warm days. Breathing these fumes can bother your lungs and air passages.
• Risks from Food: This is the most serious risk for a vegetable garden. Plants can take up chemicals from the soil through their roots. This means the vegetables you grow could have harmful chemicals in them. Eating these vegetables could expose you to substances linked to cancer and other health problems. This is a direct link between creosote leaching health risks and what you put on your dinner plate. Even if the plants don’t absorb the chemicals, the soil itself is contaminated, and you handle that soil when gardening.

Are Railroad Ties Safe For Vegetable Gardens?

Based on the risks of chemicals leaching into the soil and potentially into food, most garden and health experts say no, are railroad ties safe for vegetable gardens is not true. They are not considered safe. The risk of contaminating your soil and food with harmful chemicals is too high.

While they might seem okay for flower beds or path edging where you don’t grow food, even then, the chemicals can harm pets or children who touch the wood or the nearby soil. And the chemicals can still move into the wider environment.

What About Old Railroad Ties Gardening Use?

People often ask if old railroad ties gardening use is safer than using newer ones. The idea is that maybe years of rain and sun have washed away the worst of the chemicals.

Sadly, this is not true for creosote. Creosote is designed to stay in the wood for decades. It doesn’t wash out easily. While some surface chemicals might fade over time, the bulk of the creosote deep inside the tie remains.

Studies have shown that even very old ties still release harmful levels of chemicals into the soil. So, using old railroad ties gardening use still carries significant risks for leaching and contamination. You should treat old ties with the same caution as newer ones.

Rules About Treated Wood

Because of the risks, there are rules about how treated wood like railroad ties can be used and thrown away. In many places, you cannot use railroad ties in ways where they might touch drinking water sources or where they will be in close contact with people, especially children. This includes playgrounds and, by strong suggestion from environmental groups and some government bodies, vegetable gardens.

Throwing away railroad ties often requires special steps. They are considered hazardous waste in some areas because of the creosote. This tells you how seriously the chemicals are viewed.

Considering Alternatives to Railroad Tie Garden Beds

Since railroad ties are not safe for growing food, what are better choices? Luckily, there are many excellent and safe alternatives to railroad tie garden beds. Building raised beds without railroad ties is easy and gives you peace of mind about your soil and food.

Here are some popular materials for building raised beds without railroad ties:

• New, Untreated Lumber: Pine, fir, or spruce lumber that has NOT been treated with chemicals is a common choice.
  • Pros: Easy to find, work with, and relatively cheap.
  • Cons: Will rot over time, usually lasting 5-10 years depending on climate and wood type.
  • Safety: Safe for vegetable gardens as long as it’s genuinely untreated. Look for stamps like “HT” (Heat Treated) which is safe, not chemical treatment codes.
• Naturally Rot-Resistant Wood: Cedar and redwood are good examples.
  • Pros: Naturally resist rot and insects without chemicals. Last much longer than untreated pine (10-20 years or more). Look very nice.
  • Cons: More expensive than untreated lumber.
  • Safety: Very safe for vegetable gardens.
• Composite Lumber: Made from recycled plastic and wood fibers.
  • Pros: Very long-lasting, does not rot, warp, or splinter. Needs almost no upkeep. Often made from recycled materials.
  • Cons: Can be more expensive than wood. Some types can get brittle over many years of sun exposure. Make sure it’s rated for ground contact and food use if possible (though most modern types are considered safe).
  • Safety: Generally considered safe for vegetable gardens. Look for products made specifically for landscaping or decking.
• Stone or Brick: Building walls from natural stone or brick.
  • Pros: Extremely durable, lasts forever. Looks beautiful and natural.
  • Cons: Can be more expensive and harder to build than wood beds. Requires masonry skills or hiring help.
  • Safety: Completely safe.
• Concrete Blocks: Hollow or solid concrete blocks.
  • Pros: Durable, relatively inexpensive, easy to stack.
  • Cons: Can look less natural than wood or stone. The look might not appeal to everyone.
  • Safety: Generally considered safe.
• Metal: Corrugated metal panels or specific metal garden bed kits (like galvanized steel, corten steel, or aluminum).
  • Pros: Modern look, very durable, does not rot. Lightweight kits are easy to set up.
  • Cons: Can get hot in the sun (though soil usually insulates roots). Some metals like galvanized steel might release tiny amounts of zinc over time, but this is usually not a concern for plant or human health in normal garden settings. Corten steel rusts to form a protective layer, which some people like the look of.
  • Safety: Considered safe for vegetable gardens.
• Recycled Plastic Lumber: Made entirely from recycled plastic.
  • Pros: Very durable, lasts a very long time, does not rot or splinter. Made from waste materials.
  • Cons: Can be more expensive. Can sometimes look a bit “plastic-y.”
  • Safety: Considered safe for vegetable gardens.

When thinking about treated wood raised garden beds safety, it’s important to know that the chemicals used to treat wood have changed over the years. Older treated wood often used Chromated Copper Arsenate (CCA), which contained arsenic. Newer treatments use different chemicals like Alkaline Copper Quat (ACQ) or Copper Azole (CA). While these newer treatments are thought to be less toxic than CCA, the EPA and garden experts still advise caution when using any chemically treated wood for vegetable gardens. There’s still a chance of chemical leaching. Untreated or naturally resistant wood is always the safest choice for food crops.

Here’s a simple table comparing some materials:

Material	Cost (Low to High)	Durability	Ease of Building	Safety for Food Gardens	Look
Untreated Pine/Fir	Low	Low (5-10 yrs)	Easy	High	Natural Wood
Cedar/Redwood	Medium to High	High (10-20+ yrs)	Medium	High	Natural Wood
Composite Lumber	High	Very High	Medium	High	Varies (Looks like wood)
Stone/Brick	High	Very High	Hard	Very High	Natural Stone/Brick
Concrete Blocks	Low to Medium	Very High	Medium	High	Industrial/Plain
Metal (Galvanized Steel)	Medium	Very High	Easy	High	Modern/Industrial
Recycled Plastic Lumber	High	Very High	Medium	High	Varies (Looks like wood)
Railroad Ties	Very Low/Free	Very High	Medium	Low (Not Recommended)	Rustic/Industrial

As you can see, there are many safe, strong, and attractive options for building raised beds without railroad ties. You don’t have to risk your health or your garden’s health to build a sturdy bed.

Prioritizing Garden Safety

Making sure your garden is a safe place to grow food is key. The soil is the base of your garden. You want that soil to be as clean and healthy as possible. Using materials that can put toxic chemicals garden beds should be avoided, especially for growing vegetables, herbs, or fruits.

Think about why you are gardening. For many, it’s to grow fresh, healthy food for themselves and their families. Using railroad ties goes against this goal by introducing potential contaminants. The peace of mind that comes from knowing your raised beds are built with safe materials is worth far more than the low cost of old railroad ties.

If you already have raised beds made from railroad ties and are worried:

1. Do not grow food crops in them. Use them only for ornamental plants like flowers, shrubs, or trees that are not eaten.
2. Add a strong plastic liner. Line the inside of the ties completely with thick pond liner or heavy-duty construction plastic sheeting. Make sure the plastic covers the bottom edge where the tie meets the soil too, overlapping well. This might help reduce leaching into the main soil area, but it’s not a perfect solution and leaching can still occur over the top edge or through gaps. It also doesn’t stop contact risks with the wood itself.
3. Build a new bed inside. Build a smaller, safe raised bed (using untreated wood or other safe materials) inside the railroad tie frame. Leave a gap between the inner bed and the ties, and line the inner bed well. This uses the railroad ties as an outer, non-contact wall, but it takes up space.
4. Consider replacing them. The safest option is to remove the railroad ties and replace them with one of the safe alternative materials mentioned above. Dispose of the ties according to local hazardous waste rules. Replace the top layer of soil that was in direct contact with the ties.

Making informed choices about the materials you use is part of being a good gardener. It protects your plants, your family, and the environment around your garden.

Grasping the Long-Term View

While railroad ties are cheap and strong right now, think about the future. A raised bed built with railroad ties introduces a long-term source of pollution into your garden soil. Creosote breaks down very slowly. The leaching from railroad ties into soil can continue for many years. This means your soil could be contaminated for a long time, even after the ties are removed.

Choosing safe materials like untreated wood, stone, or metal is an investment in the long-term health and safety of your garden space. You build it once with safe materials and can feel confident growing food in it for years to come.

The potential health risks of railroad tie gardens, especially the creosote leaching health risks, are simply too significant to ignore for a space dedicated to growing food. Why take the chance when so many safe and effective alternatives to railroad tie garden beds exist?

Building raised beds without railroad ties is not difficult. It just requires choosing different materials at the start. The wide range of options means you can find materials that fit your budget, your building skills, and the look you want for your garden, all while keeping safety as the top priority.

Remember the LSI keywords we talked about:
* creosote railroad ties garden safety – The creosote is the main safety problem.
* toxic chemicals garden beds – Creosote puts these chemicals into your beds.
* alternatives to railroad tie garden beds – Many safe options exist.
* leaching from railroad ties into soil – This is how chemicals spread.
* are railroad ties safe for vegetable gardens – Generally, no.
* building raised beds without railroad ties – A recommended approach.
* treated wood raised garden beds safety – Be careful with any treated wood for food.
* health risks of railroad tie gardens – Skin, breathing, and eating contaminated food risks.
* old railroad ties gardening use – Still risky, even when old.
* creosote leaching health risks – The specific dangers of chemicals getting into food.

All these points lead to the same conclusion: for a safe and healthy vegetable garden, avoid using railroad ties.

FAQ – Your Questions Answered

Q: Is there any way to seal railroad ties to make them safe?
A: While you can try to seal or line them, experts generally do not recommend relying on this for vegetable gardens. Creosote is very hard to contain completely. It can still leach over the top edges, through gaps, or if the liner is damaged. It doesn’t make them truly safe for growing food.

Q: What should I do if I already have a vegetable garden made with railroad ties?
A: The safest thing to do is remove the ties and replace them with a safe material. Dispose of the ties properly as treated wood waste. If you cannot remove them right away, do not grow food crops in them. Use them only for non-food plants, or consider building a smaller, fully lined, safe bed inside the existing ties.

Q: Can I use railroad ties for flower beds instead of vegetable beds?
A: Using them for flower beds or borders not meant for food is less risky in terms of eating contaminated food. However, the chemicals can still leach into the soil and potentially harm pets or children who dig in the soil or touch the wood. They can also affect groundwater. Many people still choose to avoid them entirely due to these broader environmental and contact risks.

Q: How long do chemicals leach from railroad ties?
A: Creosote is designed to be long-lasting. Chemicals can continue to leach from railroad ties for many decades, even 50 years or more. Age does not make them safe.

Q: How do I dispose of old railroad ties?
A: You cannot usually put railroad ties in regular trash or recycling. They are often classified as hazardous waste because of the creosote. Contact your local waste disposal authority or recycling center to ask about the proper way to get rid of treated wood or railroad ties in your area.

Q: Are all treated woods unsafe for garden beds?
A: Not all treated woods are the same. Newer treatments are considered less toxic than old ones (like CCA which contained arsenic). However, environmental and health agencies still advise caution. Untreated wood (especially naturally resistant types like cedar) or non-wood materials are generally considered the safest options for vegetable gardens. Always check what chemical was used if considering treated wood, but err on the side of caution for food crops.

Q: How can I build a raised bed cheaply without railroad ties?
A: Untreated pine or fir lumber is often the cheapest wood option, although it won’t last as long as treated wood or naturally resistant types. Concrete blocks can also be very cost-effective. Using found or recycled materials like rocks, bricks (check they are structural and not fly ash bricks sometimes used in older construction, although most standard bricks are fine), or even straw bales (for temporary beds) can also lower costs.

By choosing safe materials, you build a garden that provides not just food, but health and peace of mind. Avoid the risks of railroad ties and enjoy growing in a safe space.