The Definitive Answer To Can I Kill Squirrels In My Yard

Image Source: crittercontroloflakecounty.com

The Definitive Answer To Can I Kill Squirrels In My Yard

So, can you kill squirrels in your yard? The short answer is: Maybe, but likely only under specific conditions and often with rules, permits, or the help of a professional. It’s not as simple as just deciding to do it because they are a bother; wildlife, even common squirrels, is usually protected by state and local laws. You need to know the squirrel killing laws in your exact area.

Deciphering the Rules

Why isn’t the answer a simple yes or no? Wildlife is seen as a shared resource. Because of this, governments at the state and local levels make rules about what you can and can’t do with it. This includes common animals like squirrels. The legal status of killing squirrels depends entirely on where you live and often why you want to kill them.

Why Rules Exist

Rules about wildlife, even squirrels, are in place for several important reasons:

• Protecting animal populations: While some animals are plentiful, rules help manage populations and prevent unnecessary harm.
• Making sure methods are safe: Laws try to stop dangerous actions like shooting guns in neighborhoods without care.
• Promoting humane treatment: Rules often push for methods that cause the least suffering if an animal must be removed or killed.
• Dealing with property damage from squirrels: Rules often lay out the right steps to take when squirrels cause problems, making sure people don’t just kill them without thinking.

State by State Differences

This is the biggest part. State regulations on killing squirrels are not the same everywhere. What’s okay in one state might be illegal in the next.

• Some states might classify certain types of squirrels (like gray squirrels or fox squirrels) as “game animals” during certain times of the year. This means you might be able to hunt them only during hunting season, with a hunting license, and following all hunting rules (like what kind of weapon, time of day, etc.). This almost never applies to just killing them in your yard because they are being a nuisance.
• Other states might classify them as “unprotected” or “nuisance wildlife” under specific circumstances, especially when they are causing property damage from squirrels. Even then, there are usually rules about how you can kill them and whether you need a permit.
• Some states require you to try non-lethal methods first before you can even think about lethal options.

Knowing your specific state’s rules is the most important step. This falls under general nuisance wildlife control laws.

When Rules Allow Killing

Usually, if state regulations on killing squirrels allow you to kill them when they are causing trouble, it’s because they are:

• Causing significant property damage from squirrels. This could be chewing on your house, getting into attics, destroying gardens, or damaging electrical wires.
• A threat to health or safety. (This is less common for squirrels but can apply to other animals).

Even when allowed for these reasons, there are almost always limits on the method you can use and often a requirement for a permit.

Permits and Licensing

Do you need permits for squirrel removal if you plan to kill them? In many places, yes.

• If squirrels are damaging your property and your state’s nuisance wildlife control laws allow for lethal removal in such cases, you might still need to apply for a permit from the state’s wildlife agency (like the Department of Fish and Wildlife or Department of Natural Resources).
• This permit process helps the state track wildlife interactions and ensures people know the rules.
• Getting a permit might require you to prove that you’ve tried non-lethal methods first and they didn’t work.
• Using lethal methods without the required permits for squirrel removal can lead to fines and legal problems.

Dealing with Nuisance Squirrels First

Before you even think about the legal status of killing squirrels or getting permits for squirrel removal, it’s almost always required (and better!) to try to handle the problem without harming the animal. This is a core part of dealing with nuisance squirrels.

Why Non-Lethal Options Are Best

There are good reasons to start with methods that don’t kill the squirrel:

• It’s often required by law: Many nuisance wildlife control laws say you must try to scare, exclude, or humanely trap and relocate before lethal control is an option.
• It’s more humane: These methods avoid causing pain or suffering.
• It addresses the cause: Killing one squirrel might just make space for another one to move in if you don’t fix why they are coming to your yard (food, shelter).
• It’s safer: Less risk of accidental harm to pets, children, or yourself compared to using traps or weapons.

Making Your Yard Less Appealing

Squirrels come to your yard because it offers them something they need: food, water, or shelter. Take these things away, and they might leave on their own. This is the first step in dealing with nuisance squirrels.

• Remove Food Sources:

  • Bird Feeders: This is a huge one. Squirrels are experts at getting birdseed. Use squirrel-proof feeders, put feeders on poles away from jumping points, or take feeders down for a while.
  • Pet Food: Don’t leave pet food bowls outside, especially overnight.
  • Garbage: Use heavy bins with locking lids that squirrels can’t chew through or knock over. Store bins in a shed or garage until pick-up day.
  • Gardens: Squirrels dig up bulbs, eat fruits, and veggies. Use netting, fencing, or repellent sprays (natural like capsaicin or commercial options). Bury hardware cloth under bulbs.
  • Trees: Harvest fruits and nuts as soon as they ripen. Clean up any that fall to the ground.

• Remove Water Sources: While less common as a primary draw, make sure there are no leaky pipes or standing water attracting them, especially in dry times.

• Remove Shelter/Nesting Spots:

  • Trim tree branches that hang close to your house. Squirrels use these as bridges to your roof and attic.
  • Clean up brush piles, old cars, or other clutter where they might hide or build nests.

Blocking Access

Squirrels are very good climbers and can squeeze into small spaces. Preventing them from getting into your house, garage, or sheds is key in dealing with nuisance squirrels.

• Inspect Your Home: Walk around your house and look for any holes or gaps.
  • Check the roof, especially around chimneys, vents, and eaves.
  • Look at siding, fascia boards, and soffits.
  • Check around pipes and wires entering the house.
  • Look at the foundation.
• Seal Entry Points:
  • Use sturdy materials like wire mesh (hardware cloth, 1/4 inch or 1/2 inch size is best) or metal flashing. Don’t use flimsy materials like plastic or screen that they can chew through.
  • Repair damaged areas quickly.
  • Install chimney caps.
  • Cover vents with mesh.
  • Check your attic for light showing through from the outside, which points to entry holes.
• Be Careful Sealing: Make sure squirrels are not inside when you seal up holes. Sealing them inside means they will try desperately to get out (causing more damage) or die inside (leading to bad smells and other problems). You might need to watch the hole for a while to see squirrels coming and going, or even use a temporary one-way door (designed for wildlife) that lets them out but not back in.

If Non-Lethal Fails and It’s Legal

Let’s say you’ve tried everything to scare them away and block entry, they are causing major property damage from squirrels, and you’ve checked your local squirrel killing laws and found that lethal removal is an option in your specific situation, and you have obtained any necessary permits for squirrel removal. What’s next?

Legal Lethal Choices

If killing a squirrel is legal where you are and you have the right to do it, you must use humane lethal methods for squirrels. This means the method should cause death quickly and with the least possible pain and suffering to the animal.

Methods that are generally not considered humane or are outright illegal include:

• Poison: Almost always illegal for squirrels. It’s hard to control where they die (often inside walls), can cause slow, painful deaths, and can poison other animals (pets, wildlife) that eat the poisoned squirrel or the bait. This is a major safety risk and rarely a legal option for squirrels.
• Glue traps: Extremely inhumane. Animals get stuck and suffer greatly before dying from stress, starvation, or injury trying to escape.
• Drowning: Illegal and inhumane.

Using Traps

If lethal methods are allowed, traps are one common way people try to deal with squirrels. However, you must use the right type and use it correctly. Knowing the best traps for killing squirrels that are legal in your area is key.

• Lethal Snap Traps: There are heavy-duty snap traps made specifically for squirrels (larger and stronger than mouse or rat traps).
  • How they work: Designed to kill instantly by breaking the neck or skull when the squirrel triggers it.
  • Humane? If placed and used correctly, they can be humane by causing quick death. If used incorrectly (e.g., too small, wrong placement), they can injure instead of kill, leading to suffering.
  • Legality: Generally legal for this purpose if lethal control is allowed. Must be placed carefully away from pets and children.
  • Placement: Put them along squirrel pathways, near entry points, or where they are causing damage. Bait them (peanut butter, nuts).
• Body-Gripping Traps (like Conibear traps): These traps are designed to kill the animal quickly when it passes through.
  • Legality: Often restricted or illegal for use in residential areas or near homes due to the risk to pets. They are often used by licensed trappers in specific situations. You must check your local and state rules very carefully before even thinking about using this type of trap. Misuse can lead to serious legal problems.
  • Humane? If sized correctly for the animal and placed properly, they can be humane by killing quickly.
• Live Traps (Cage Traps): While these catch the animal alive, they are often used when the plan is lethal removal after capture.
  • How they work: Lure the animal into a cage, and the door closes behind it.
  • Why used for lethal control: In some places, it might be legal to humanely kill a squirrel caught in a live trap, even if other lethal methods are restricted. However, relocating squirrels caught in live traps is often illegal without a permit and can be harmful to the squirrel (stress, inability to find food/shelter in a new area).
  • If used for lethal control: The animal must be humanely killed immediately after capture using a legal and humane method (often stated in regulations). You cannot just leave it in the trap to die.

Using best traps for killing squirrels requires reading the trap instructions carefully, understanding animal behavior, and knowing the law. Placement is key for effectiveness and safety.

Other Methods (Use with Extreme Caution and Legal Check)

• Shooting: In some rural areas, and if explicitly allowed by local laws and done safely, shooting might be a legal option.
  • Legality: This is highly restricted or illegal in most populated or suburban areas due to safety risks (stray bullets). You need to know local firearm or pellet gun ordinances.
  • Weapon: If allowed, a small-caliber rifle or a powerful air rifle/pellet gun is typically used. Using a regular firearm in a residential area is often illegal.
  • Humane? Only if the shooter is highly skilled and can guarantee an instant, clean kill. A poor shot can cause severe suffering.
  • Safety: This is paramount. You must have a safe backdrop and be absolutely sure of your target and what’s beyond it.

Let’s summarize non-lethal vs. lethal in a simple table.

Method Category	Examples	Typical Legality (Check Local!)	Humane? (If done right)	Notes
Non-Lethal	Remove food/water, exclusion (sealing holes)	Generally always legal & preferred	Yes	Addresses the cause, prevents future problems. Often required first.
	Repellents, scare tactics	Generally always legal	Yes	May have limited or temporary success.
	Live Trapping (for relocation)	Often illegal without permit	Can be stressful	Relocation itself is often harmful to the animal and might be illegal.
Lethal	Lethal Snap Traps (squirrel size)	Often legal if lethal control is allowed	Yes (if instant kill)	Must be placed safely away from pets/kids.
	Body-Gripping Traps (Conibear)	Often restricted/illegal in residential areas	Yes (if instant kill)	High risk to non-target animals (pets). Requires expertise & legal check.
	Shooting (Rifle/Pellet Gun)	Highly restricted/illegal in populated areas	Yes (if instant kill)	Safety is a huge concern. Requires skill and legal confirmation.
	Poison	Almost always illegal	No	Inhumane, unsafe (pets, wildlife, environment), unpredictable.
	Drowning	Illegal	No	Extremely inhumane.

Remember: This table gives general ideas. YOU MUST CHECK YOUR SPECIFIC LOCAL AND STATE LAWS.

When to Call a Pro

For most people dealing with nuisance squirrels, the safest, easiest, and most legally sound approach is to call a wildlife control professional.

What a Professional Does

A wildlife control professional specializes in handling animal problems, including squirrels. They offer many benefits:

• They Know the Law: A good professional is up-to-date on all squirrel killing laws, nuisance wildlife control laws, and state regulations on killing squirrels in your area. They know when lethal methods are allowed and when they are not.
• They Handle Permits: If permits for squirrel removal are needed for the required method, they will often obtain these permits themselves as part of their service.
• They Use Proper Methods: They are trained in humane lethal methods for squirrels if lethal control is necessary and legal. They know how to use best traps for killing squirrels safely and effectively, or they can perform humane euthanasia if required after live capture (and if allowed by law).
• They Find the Root Cause: They can find out why squirrels are attracted to your yard and where they are getting in. They don’t just remove the animal; they help you solve the underlying problem.
• They Have the Right Gear: They have access to specialized tools, traps, and safety equipment you might not have.
• They Ensure Safety: They know how to handle wildlife safely and how to place traps or use other methods without putting your family or pets at risk.
• They Handle Removal and Cleanup: They will properly remove the animal (dead or alive) and can often help with cleaning up messes or repairing damage the squirrels caused.

Hiring a qualified wildlife control professional takes the guesswork out of a complicated situation and helps ensure everything is done legally and safely. Look for professionals who are licensed and insured and who follow humane practices. You can often find listings through your state’s wildlife agency or professional pest control associations.

Key Rules to Remember

To make sure you stay within the legal status of killing squirrels and handle the problem correctly, always remember these key points:

Check Your Local Area

• State Wildlife Agency: Contact your state’s Department of Fish and Wildlife, Department of Natural Resources, or similar agency. This is the best source for accurate information on state regulations on killing squirrels, nuisance wildlife control laws, and whether permits for squirrel removal are needed. Their websites often have guides.
• Local Ordinances: Check with your city or county clerk. There might be local rules about trapping, discharging firearms (even pellet guns), or other methods in residential areas.
• Homeowners Association (HOA): If you have an HOA, check their rules too. They might have specific guidelines about wildlife interactions.

Prioritize Non-Lethal

Always start by trying to make your yard less attractive and blocking entry points. This is often legally required anyway and is the most effective long-term solution for dealing with nuisance squirrels.

Use Humane Methods If Legal

If lethal control is permitted and necessary, you must use humane lethal methods for squirrels that result in a quick death. Poison is almost never legal or humane.

Get Permits If Needed

Don’t assume you can just kill a squirrel causing property damage from squirrels. In many cases, lethal removal of nuisance wildlife requires specific permits for squirrel removal.

Consider a Professional

If you are unsure about the laws, methods, or safety, call a wildlife control professional. They are experts and can handle the situation correctly.

What Happens If You Break the Rules

Ignoring squirrel killing laws or using illegal methods can lead to serious problems. The legal status of killing squirrels isn’t just a suggestion; it carries weight.

Penalties

• Fines: You can face significant fines for illegally killing wildlife, using illegal methods (like poison), or trapping/killing without necessary permits for squirrel removal.
• Legal Trouble: In some cases, repeated offenses or particularly bad actions could lead to more serious legal consequences.
• Bad Publicity: Using inhumane methods or ignoring the law can lead to negative reactions from neighbors or the community.

Wildlife laws are there to manage animal populations, ensure public safety, and promote humane treatment. Following them is important.

Grasping the Situation

Squirrels can definitely be a bother, causing frustrating property damage from squirrels. They can chew wires, ruin gardens, and make noise in your attic. It’s understandable to want them gone. However, deciding to kill them is not a simple personal choice because of squirrel killing laws and the legal status of killing squirrels.

You must research nuisance wildlife control laws, understand state regulations on killing squirrels, and determine if permits for squirrel removal are required. You must also commit to using humane lethal methods for squirrels if lethal control is legal and necessary.

For most homeowners, the best path forward when dealing with nuisance squirrels is to focus on making your property less appealing and securing entry points. If that fails and the problem is severe, consulting with or hiring a qualified wildlife control professional is often the most effective and legally compliant way to resolve the issue. They can navigate the complexities of the law and safely implement the necessary steps.

Never use poison or other clearly inhumane and likely illegal methods. Always verify the specific rules in your exact location before taking any action beyond simple exclusion or scare tactics. The “definitive answer” isn’t a simple yes or no to killing; it’s a definite YES to researching your local laws and acting responsibly.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Here are some common questions people ask about squirrels in the yard.

Is it legal to kill squirrels in my backyard?

Maybe, but it depends heavily on your specific state and local laws. In many places, it is illegal unless they are causing significant damage and you follow specific rules, which might include getting a permit or using certain methods. Often, you are required to try non-lethal methods first.

Do I need a permit to remove or kill a squirrel?

Often, yes, if you plan to use lethal methods or even trap and relocate them. Permits for squirrel removal are usually issued by your state’s wildlife agency when dealing with nuisance animals lethally. Always check with your state wildlife agency.

Can I use poison to kill squirrels?

Almost never. Using poison for squirrels is generally illegal across the United States. It is considered inhumane and poses severe risks to pets, other wildlife, and even people.

What are humane lethal methods for squirrels if killing is allowed?

If legal and necessary, humane methods aim for a quick death with minimal suffering. This often involves using specific, heavy-duty snap traps designed for squirrels, placed correctly to ensure an instant kill. Shooting might be considered humane if done by a skilled person with the right weapon and if legal in that specific location, but it’s often restricted.

What are the best traps for killing squirrels?

If legal lethal trapping is an option, heavy-duty snap traps designed for squirrels (larger than rat traps) can be effective and humane if used correctly. Body-gripping traps (like Conibear) can be effective but are often illegal or restricted in residential areas due to risk to pets.

Can I just trap a squirrel in a cage and move it somewhere else?

Often, no. Relocating wildlife, including squirrels, is frequently illegal without a permit from the state wildlife agency. Also, relocating squirrels can cause them stress and they often struggle to find food, water, or shelter in a new area, leading to their death.

A squirrel is damaging my house. Can I kill it then?

Maybe, but you still need to follow the rules. Damage from squirrels is often a reason states allow lethal control, but you usually must comply with nuisance wildlife control laws, possibly get permits for squirrel removal, and use only humane lethal methods for squirrels. Blocking entry points is usually the better long-term solution.

Should I call a professional wildlife control service?

Yes, if you’re unsure about the laws, methods, or safety. A wildlife control professional knows the squirrel killing laws and state regulations on killing squirrels, can legally obtain permits for squirrel removal if needed, uses safe and legal methods, and can help prevent future problems. They are often the best resource for dealing with nuisance squirrels.